Horry Scale: Teague Time

VIDEO: Teague’s Winner

ALL BALL NERVE CENTER — Perhaps you thought you were done unwrapping presents, but tonight in Cleveland, the Hawks and Cavs had one last gift for you. It was one of the most entertaining games of the season, so of course it had to end (not in regulation, not in overtime, but in double overtime) with a game-winning buzzer-beater from Hawks guard Jeff Teague.

Before we get too far into this, we should stop and explain: What is the Horry Scale? For those who are new around these parts, the Horry Scale examines a game-winning buzzer-beater (GWBB) in the categories of difficulty, game situation (was the team tied or behind at the time?), importance (playoff game or garden-variety Kings-Pistons game?) and celebration (is it over the top or too chill? Just the right panache or needs more sauce?). Then we give it an overall grade on a scale of 1-5 Robert Horrys, the patron saint of last-second daggers.

With the rules in place, tonight we look to the shores of Lake Erie, to Cleveland, where Jeff Teague could not be stopped…not even by Uncle Drew.

To be fair, it wasn’t the toughest shot in the world — Teague drove left and pulled up for the right-handed jumper, kind of like Hawks guard Mike Bibby used to do. The simple genius in this play was the Hawks running Paul Millsap at Teague with about 6 seconds left to ostensibly set a screen. Millsap got to Teague and set what was basically a token screen, and the Cavs switched the pick. Now, we’ve talked about switching picks here previously — pretty much every NBA team switches picks in the final seconds because the last thing you want is someone who is totally unguarded. You might end up with a mismatch, but at least you’ve got someone defending everyone. On this play, that meant the Cavs went from having Kyrie Irving on Teague to having the 6-foot-9 Tristan Thompson guarding Teague. (Kyrie, by the way, was equally huge tonight, finishing with 40 points and 9 assists). This is what is known as a mismatch, and it only took Teague a few dribbles to shake Thompson and clear room for the last-second shot.

It is in this category that this shot really soars. To begin with, Teague missed a floater with seconds left in regulation that would have broken the tie at 95. Not long into the first overtime, Hawks All-Star center Al Horford had an injury to what appeared to be his right shoulder/chest that took him out of the game, and forced the Hawks to use a variety of makeshift lineups down the stretch. With about 7 seconds left in OT and the Hawks down three, Teague drained a long three-pointer to tie the game at 108. Then with 2.4 seconds left in overtime, the Hawks had a shot at a GWBB from the baseline that Teague couldn’t connect on, sending the game into double OT. In the second OT, Teague had a huge drive-and-one to give the Hawks a 125-123 lead, and then with the game level at 125, Teague ended it. Basically, the situation couldn’t have been much more dramatic. And Teague put the bow on top.

I’m going to lump the ball going through the rim as part of the celebration, because it doesn’t really fit anywhere else (it’s not “difficulty,” it’s just lucky) and that was a huge part of what made this such a great shot. The ball hit the rim five times, I believe, and it may have even kissed the glass somwhere in there, all while the buzzer was sounding in the background and you wondered, “It’s not going to…no way…that can’t…ohmygoshhemadeit!” And then after the ball drops, you see Teague laying flat on the ground celebrating — not only the GWBB but also a career-high 34 points — with Kyle Korver pounding on his chest. This was the first prone Horry Scale celebration of the season, I believe.

For reasons that will become evident in the next week or so, I watched this game intently from the Turner Studios in Atlanta, and the deeper the game went, the more sure I was that we’d have a GWBB. It was an exciting, close game, and it had an equally exciting finish. So for all the reasons detailed above, I’m giving this Four Horrys. I thought seriously about giving this a Five just because it was such a great game, but I felt the actual shot could have had a bit of a higher degree of difficulty.

horry-star horry-star horry-star horry-star

What say you? How many Horrys would you give Jeff Teague’s GWBB?


  1. ABK034 says:

    haha, there’s been so much hate for the your horry scale – great idea but you got it wrong from the start. This shot wasn’t ranked too bad however, but not in comparison to other rankings. Sorry to bring it back (again) to Jeff Greens shot, but in no way was Teauges better. 3 & 1/2 Horry’s at best for this – 4 & 5 should be reserved for the truly special

    • mghbnz says:

      You got it all wrong Mr Whitaker… this deserves 3 Horrys at best. And yes ABK034 Jeff Greens shot deserved a lot more than it got

    • Hey says:

      Agreed, green’s should get 5 or teague’s should drop to 2 or 3.

      • rrski says:

        its very simple no matter how easy the shot might be once fatigue factors in it would be very difficult take note that happened in double OT you never imagine how tired Teague is while taking that shot

  2. Chad says:

    this is a 2.5 or 3 at best….

    Not a swish – bounced all over the place meaning it would very well have not gone in.
    Not a 3 pointer – easier shot than a 2 pointer
    Not a playoff game – regular season game against a non-playoff team
    Game tied shot – Not as much pressure compared to a points behind shot. If you miss just try again in overtime.

  3. ism says:

    i am repeating myself: this scale is fun idea but you have to make it 10 horrys instead of 5 so that you avoid all these contradictuous ratings. that way it would be SERIOUS fun.

  4. joenba says:

    3 horry’s max, man. weak shot. and there were tied anyways not much at risk.

  5. Guy from Atlanta says:

    Teague was actually on the ground because Tristan Thompson tripped him on accident in the end there, so … yeah.

  6. Pétrus says:

    The horry scale this year is being messed up by whitaker, i agree with the guys here, 3 horrys at most, giving horrys just because Teague had the best game of his career (So far) doesn’t matter for the horry scale, just look at the situation.

    1°: the game was tied, this speaks for itself
    2°: Teague actully had a little room to get the shot off
    3°: It was against the cavs, they don’t have much hope to get to the playoffs, even with varejao healthy (I’m Brazilian)

    I would give 3 horrys, 2 horrys if the shot was a layup…

    What do you think of my rating guys?

  7. Roy says:

    Nobody has the right to complain about this scale or anything of the ratings, it’s 95% opinion any ways.

    If people are so angry at each others ratings why not let people have some more accurate options and do a 1-10 Horry scale?

  8. Dani3lson says:

    If Teague get 4 horrys, Jeff Green should get 5.

    • euar says:

      if Teague get 4, Jeff Green should get 7 or 8 horrys
      1. Teague have about 10 seconds
      2. he get 6-foot-9 Tristan Thompson guarding him. its mismatch
      3. not a clean shot
      4.game was tied
      Teague shold get 2 horrys.

  9. AustralianZac says:

    Horry scale lost meaning last year, and it has free falled since.
    Change to 10 stars and re-evaluate every GWBB this season.

  10. bartek says:

    I agree. Please make it 10 grade scale. It would be much easier – both for You and for fans.

  11. dustydreamnz says:

    I agree, 10 stars be better.

  12. thehorryscalesavior says:

    make it on a 10 star system so every shot is not 3 or 4 stars

  13. BE says:

    only a 3 Horry, the game had little meanning beyond regular season, not a playoff game, did not when a series

  14. Game Time says:

    Still no post on Bosh’s game winner which was a 5+ based on this grading scale. It’s ok, I know Lang hates Miami.

    • Lang Whitaker says:

      For what it’s worth, Bosh’s shot went through with 0.5 left on the clock. The Horry Scale is for shots with 0.0 left on the clock.

  15. Myke says:

    1st: it´s not a win or lose shot.
    2nd: poor defense.
    3rd: very very lucky.

    so for me it´s a 2 but just because it happened in 2nd OT.